ENTER THE 2021 SHORTY IMPACT AWARDS

Previously known as the Shorty Social Good Awards, the Shorty Impact Awards is an awards program created to raise global awareness around the positive impact brands, agencies and non-profits can have on society.

Social Campaigns

Community

Arts & Culture

Civic Engagement

Disability Awareness

Diversity, Equity & Inclusion

Gender Equality

Education & Community

Financial Literacy

Public Safety

Youth & Family

Environment

Conservation & Preservation

Sustainability & Renewable Energy

Social & Racial Justice

Animal Rights & Welfare

Humanitarian Aid & Developing Nations

Social Justice & Human Rights

Racial Justice

Veteran & Service Support

Health & Wellness

Fitness & Nutrition

Mental Health

Public Health

Reproductive Health

Grassroots

Grassroots Efforts

Self-Defined (Social Campaigns)

Self-Defined

Social Presence

Single-Platform

Clubhouse

Discord

Facebook

Instagram

LinkedIn

Pinterest

Reddit

Snapchat

TikTok

Triller

Tumblr

Twitch

Twitter

YouTube

Multi-Platform

Multi-Platform

Emerging Platform

Emerging Platform

Social Hit

Single Post or Activation (viral)

Clapback

Social Engagement

Community Management

Community Management

Engagement Tools

Access & Rewards

Call to Action

Chatbots

Contests

Gamification

Polls & Surveys

Integrated Experiences

Fundraising

Live Events

Shopping

Television

Real Time Response

Real Time Response

User Generated Content

User Generated Content

Self-Defined (Social Engagement)

Self-Defined

Social Partnerships

Brand Partnership

Celebrity Partnership

Entertainment Partnership

Influencer Partnership

Non-Profit Partnership

2021 SHORTY PHENOM AWARDS

Previously known as the Shorty Social Good Awards, the Shorty Impact Awards is an awards program created to raise global awareness around the positive impact brands, agencies and non-profits can have on society.

Individuals

Account Management

Analytics

Animation

Art Direction

Brand Marketing

Campaign Management

Communications

Community Management

Copywriting

Creative Direction

Culture

Data Analysis

Design

Editing

Illustration

Partnership Management

Photography

Production

Project Management

Public Relations

Research

Sales

Strategy

Talent Management

Self-Defined

Team

Account Team

Analytics Team

Client Team

Communications Team

Community Team

Content Team

Creative Team

Culture Team

Design Team

Legal Team

Marketing Team

Partnership Team

PR Team

Production Team

Research Team

Sales Team

Social Media Team

Strategy Team

Video Team

Self-Defined

Leader

Account Team Leader

Analytics Team Leader

Client Team Leader

Communications Team Leader

Community Team Leader

Content Team Leader

Creative Team Leader

Culture Team Leader

Design Team Leader

Legal Team Leader

Marketing Team Leader

Partnership Team Leader

PR Team Leader

Production Team Leader

Research Team Leader

Sales Team Leader

Social Media Team Leader

Strategy Team Leader

Video Team Leader

Self-Defined

Voice

Clubhouse Voice

Discord Voice

Facebook Voice

Instagram Voice

LinkedIn Voice

Pinterest Voice

Reddit Voice

TikTok Voice

Triller Voice

Tumblr Voice

Twitter Voice

YouTube Voice

From the 11th Annual Shorty Awards

How Panera Won Twitter

Finalist in Twitter Presence

About this entry

Brand salience is critical in the crowded food and beverage category, because daily decisions about what to eat are based on convenience and familiarity. At the start of 2018, salience was not on Panera's side. Total brand mentions were in a gradual, three-year decline. Our goal was to drive conversation and conquer share of voice in category, with Twitter as our primary vehicle.

The task was formidable. Panera was up against competitors' mammoth media spends. Between Sept '16 - Aug '17, McDonald's total spend was 10x Panera's; Subway, Taco Bell and Burger King's were all ~5x. Panera needed an immediate, efficient way to increase relevance with everyday consumers.

To succeed, Panera had to treat Twitter as not just a channel, but an engine of the brand's purpose of Food As It Should Be—the belief that the power of clean food* can cultivate community, reinforce food positivity, and help change a fundamentally broken industry for the better.

---------

*Panera defines clean food as no artificial preservatives, sweeteners, flavors and no colors from artificial sources.

Why does this entry deserve to win?

We set out to dominate food culture through a social-first strategy and generate mass conversation around our brand and products. On Twitter, we clocked up to 3,000 unaided mentions of Panera per month—making the channel our ideal vehicle to spark brand love and galvanize our audience around key initiatives. Our strategy set the stage for three major moments in 2018:

1. Creating Real-Time Relevance

Panera's real-time system cultivates brand love by harnessing hyper-relevant moments in culture, making complicated food issues dynamic and digestible.

Case in point: when we discovered that US restaurant chains can serve "eggs" containing as many as 16 ingredients, Panera petitioned the FDA to define the term "egg" as one ingredient—forcing our competitors to clean up their acts.

The petition was a provocative challenge bound to generate conversation, and when Twitter Queen Chrissy Teigen tweeted in support of real eggs, we were ready. She suggested that we should call our Broccoli Cheddar Soup "Delicious Cream Times," and we promptly made her a customized "Delicious Cream Times" soup and delivered it to her door, earning yet another tweet. Panera even changed the name of the Broccoli Cheddar Soup on our e-commerce site, earning headlines from the press.

2. Sparking Social-Led Product Innovation

Social listening can lead to some amazing things, including new menu items.

Through social listening, we saw that #PaneraDate garners clear, consistent behavior from our fans, who share their moments in cafe together. Naturally, we paid off that behavior with a product that's made to be shared: The Double Bread Bowl.

Launching in one test market (Philadelphia) as a limited-time-only menu item, the Double Bread Bowl dominated social media conversation before cafes could open their doors.

A total of 231 publishers picked up the story, resulting in over 498 million earned impressions.

3. Making our Name in Meme Culture

Since we aim to differentiate in category and in-feed, what better way to do that than to double down on our most iconic asset: Bread.

This strategic point of differentiation gave us permission to jump on a rising meme—Let's Get This Bread.

The team acted with a single tweet. No paid media. Zero dollars spent on production.

After the tweet went live, retweets and @mentions soared, and the Panera team was all-hands on deck, sparking 1:1 dialogue to accelerate the conversation on Twitter, even creating new memes, all in the name of bread.

Within 24 hours, the tweet spanned platforms as a meme, subsequently being featured on Reddit, Instagram, Facebook, and Tumblr. More memes poured out of the original, as fans created their own versions of "Let's Get this Bread", inspired by Panera.

"Let's Get this Bread" is the best performing tweet about Panera on Twitter. Ever.

Since our original tweet, mentions of the meme have increased by 350%.

Results

With a solid point of differentiation and a consumer-first strategy on social media, Panera dominated the conversation online, with Twitter as a primary vehicle -

1. Panera exceeded our yearly goal for brand mentions by 300%

2. We created our own top tweet, which generated 20.3MM impressions, 764K engagements, 1.7K replies, and 140K social media mentions

3. We gave fans a product made for social sharing, which doubled sales of sourdough in the first week in our test market of Philadelphia

Media

Produced by

Anomaly, Panera Bread

Link

Entry Credits